What was really behind infuriating maths test question

Can you solve this ... oh wait
Can you solve this ... oh wait Twitter

FRUSTRATED maths fans were seething at this bizarre question - but the teacher who wrote it has hit back.

The trick question about Beethoven's 9th Symphony was trending on Twitter after an alarmed person posted it.

"An orchestra of 120 players takes 40 minutes to play Beethoven's 9th symphony," the question goes. "How long would it take for 60 players to play the symphony?"

The incensed tweeter wrote: "That's not how it works. That's not how any of this works."

Thousands of commenters quickly jumped on board, saying the question makes no sense - as the number of players in the orchestra wouldn't make any difference to the length of the classic.

One tweeter wrote: "I'm so angry right now, this has ruined my whole day."

"That's like saying 'It takes 9 months for a woman to have a baby, how long would it take for 2 women to have a baby?'" posted another.

"Two options, it is a logic trap question or the question writer is an imbecile," one tweeter wrote.

Classical music fans were also confused because the Beethoven composition is supposed to last around 70 minutes.

However, original writer Claire Longmoor - a teacher from Nottingham in the UK - discovered her work being shared on Twitter, and posted a response.

The brainbox put together a selection of example questions with relationships in direct and inverse proportion over 10 years ago.

She said it was a trick question to keep students alert while making their way through the worksheet and even posted a copy of the original test.

Topics:  editors picks maths quiz social media

News Corp Australia

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Limited time to speak on new laws

FIRED UP: Whitsundays MP Jason Costigan and local farmer Ralph Cox yesterday discussing newly proposed clearing legislation.

MP Costigan said the new laws would effect Proserpine.

Students sign pledge against bullying

BULLYING? NO WAY: Proserpine High School students (back, from left) Sophie Bridge, Darcy Larkin, Porsha Hancock, Georgia Muller, Tayla Goody, Mika Stimson, Olivia McCall, Jaimie Allen and (front) Max Cornish say no to bullying on Tuesday.

Proserpine High takes week of action against bullies

Family desperate to get daughter an education

Ahn Tuyet and her step Dad Peter Burns just want to be able to afford to go to school.

MP talks local case study in overseas student bill debate

Local Partners